Change Fatigue: Why Your Teams Can’t Keep Up With Change

Illustration of change fatigue showing an overloaded employee carrying office equipment while executives prepare to add another filing cabinet.

It’s Monday morning. Half your team is missing because they’re double-booked in another “urgent” meeting, while also somehow expected to deliver a 20-page report by midday – a request that landed in their inbox at 8:14am. The rest are present in body but not in spirit, juggling three deadlines, two fires, and a half-written email to the one client who might still like you.

And that’s just one morning. Somewhere in amongst all of this, leadership has decided it’s time to introduce a new operating model, restructure two departments and roll out an AI platform that everyone needs to become proficient in by Thursday. Fortunately, someone has scheduled a mandatory two-hour workshop on time management. If you’ve ever wondered how change fatigue develops in the workplace, this is a fairly effective recipe.

Having spent years in marketing and digital leadership, I’ve been responsible for my fair share of this nonsense. There was always another opportunity, another technology I wanted to explore or a process I was convinced could be improved. I was particularly good at identifying exciting new opportunities that would require an enormous amount of somebody else’s time.

Finding ways to improve a business is relatively easy compared with finding the capacity within it to do something about those improvements.

Understanding Change Fatigue and Change Saturation

Imagine for a moment that five executives independently approved five sizeable investments without consulting one another or finding out how much money the business had available. Any half-decent finance director would be apoplectic. By lunchtime, somebody would be explaining themselves to the board and the company credit card would be locked in a small, heavily fortified bunker beneath Switzerland.

Yet we routinely do something remarkably similar with our people.

Marketing introduces a new CRM, Operations redesigns a workflow, HR launches a performance management programme and IT decides that now would be a wonderful time to migrate everyone to a new system. Each initiative has its own business case, budget, project team and enthusiastic executive sponsor. Unfortunately, many of them require the time and attention of the same people.

In its research into change saturation, Prosci found that more than 73% of respondents considered their organisations to be approaching, at or beyond the point of saturation.

Change fatigue describes the exhaustion and declining enthusiasm people can experience when repeatedly adapting to change. Change saturation occurs when the demands placed on an organisation exceed its capacity to implement and absorb those changes effectively. And while each executive might have a perfectly reasonable justification for their respective initiative, the people expected to implement them experience the cumulative effect.

Perhaps we ought to apply some of the discipline we use to manage our finances to managing our capacity for change.

Capability and Capacity Are Two Different Things

In Dan Heath’s book Reset, he describes a doughnut shop with two employees. One takes 90 seconds to process a customer’s order, while the other takes 60 seconds to cook the doughnuts. Along comes a salesperson offering a magnificent new fryer that can cook them in 30 seconds.

It’s a technological marvel. Unfortunately, the shop will still only serve a customer every 90 seconds because the person taking the orders remains the constraint. The principal achievement of this technological investment is that the doughnuts now spend an additional 30 seconds contemplating their existence.

It’s a wonderfully simple example of why systems thinking matters in business. A seemingly sensible investment can fail to improve the performance of the entire system. I suspect many organisations have their own wonderfully expensive equivalent of that fryer. Some have probably appointed a Chief Frying Officer and assembled a committee to investigate why the doughnuts haven’t generated the anticipated return on investment.

We can recruit exceptionally capable people, train them, give them excellent technology and provide them with a clear strategic direction. But if they’re already struggling to accommodate their existing commitments, how much of that additional capability are they actually going to be able to use?

This is particularly problematic in businesses with highly resilient employees. Capable, conscientious people will often find a way to deliver, even when the demands placed on them are unreasonable. They’ll work later, sacrifice their own development, postpone difficult conversations and spend their evenings catching up on the work they couldn’t get to during the day.

From the boardroom, everything might appear to be going rather well. The deadlines are being met, the dashboards are green and somebody has just suggested increasing next quarter’s targets.

I’ve written separately about business capacity planning and why understanding the resources available to us is essential to sustaining performance.


Recognising the Warning Signs of Change Fatigue

Change is frequently done to people rather than with them. Leadership announces the new direction and wonders why employees respond with roughly the same enthusiasm they’d reserve for an airline announcing, halfway across the Atlantic, that passengers would now be expected to contribute to the remaining flight by pedalling.

Sometimes people resist change because they don’t understand it or because they’re comfortable with the way things currently work. Sometimes they have legitimate concerns about the proposed solution. And sometimes they’re exhausted and can’t fathom where they’re supposed to find the time.

Some of the warning signs of change fatigue include declining enthusiasm, slower adoption of new processes, missed deadlines, irritability and an increasing reluctance to get involved in new initiatives. None of these necessarily means your people are resistant to change. The difficulty for leaders is working out what’s causing the behaviour before prescribing a solution.

Amy Edmondson’s research into psychological safety and team learning highlights the importance of creating conditions in which people feel comfortable taking interpersonal risks, admitting mistakes and asking difficult questions.

Consider how you’d respond if one of your employees told you that they thought your latest initiative was going to cause problems. Would you be curious about what they’d seen that you hadn’t? Or would you spend the next 20 minutes explaining why they needed to get on board, before sending them a PDF about the importance of embracing change?

How you handle that conversation will influence the information they bring you next time.

I’ve explored some of the behavioural challenges involved in implementing change in my article on change management psychology. Understanding why people respond the way they do can help us design a more appropriate response, rather than simply communicating the original plan with increasing levels of enthusiasm.

Three Ways Leaders Can Reduce Change Fatigue

1. Assess Your Organisation’s Capacity for Change

Get your leadership team together and make a list of every significant change initiative underway or planned over the next three months. Include technology implementations, restructures, new processes, recruitment gaps and the commitments your teams already have to deliver.

Then map which departments and individuals will be affected, how much of their time is required and when those demands will overlap.

You might discover that someone has allocated the same six people to four different strategic initiatives, all due for completion before the end of the quarter. Apparently, the entire business strategy hinges on these six individuals discovering a previously unknown dimension of time.

Having visibility of the collective demands allows you to make decisions about the business as a whole rather than managing each initiative in isolation.

2. Investigate the Causes of Change Fatigue

When an initiative starts encountering resistance or repeatedly misses milestones, go and spend time with the people involved. Ask them where they’re struggling, what other demands are competing for their attention and what they would change about the proposed approach.

Be prepared to hear something you hadn’t considered and, occasionally, something you don’t particularly want to hear.

You may discover that the solution you’ve proposed is sound but the timing is dreadful, or that an existing process is consuming the capacity needed to implement it. You may even discover that your magnificent new fryer is sitting in the wrong part of the doughnut shop.

Give people the opportunity to help you understand the problem before deciding how to resolve it.

3. Decide What You’re Going to Stop Doing

Before approving another major change initiative, establish what the people involved will be able to stop, postpone or simplify to make room for it. Where necessary, consider whether you need to allocate additional resources.

Businesses are remarkably good at starting things. Stopping them appears to require a royal commission, fourteen stakeholder consultations and the ceremonial burning of a laminated strategic roadmap.

There may be initiatives that you’ve championed personally, processes you’ve spent years developing or projects in which the business has already invested considerable money. But if a more important opportunity has emerged, continuing to allocate scarce resources to those activities can compromise your ability to pursue it.

And once you’ve improved a process or introduced technology that returns some time to your people, resist the temptation to immediately fill all of it with more work. Leave some capacity for learning, experimentation, collaboration and the unexpected demands that inevitably arrive.

Beyond Change Fatigue: Building a Business That Can Keep Up

Businesses around the world are dealing with technological disruption, geopolitical uncertainty, shifting customer expectations and competitors capable of dismantling an established business model before its leadership team has finished discussing the previous quarter’s results.

We’re asking businesses to become more efficient while simultaneously expecting them to become more adaptable. Both are perfectly reasonable ambitions, provided we appreciate that adaptability requires resources of their own. Running a business permanently at full capacity leaves very little room to explore an emerging opportunity, respond to an unexpected disruption or develop the capabilities it will need in five years.

It’s a large part of why I developed Antistable: to help leaders understand where organisational strain is accumulating and how effectively their businesses anticipate change, design appropriate responses and implement them.

If you’re seeing signs of change fatigue in your own business, I’d encourage you to start with your leadership team. Get a clear picture of the demands you’re collectively placing on your people, find out where they’re struggling and make some deliberate decisions about what no longer deserves their time.

You might discover that the capabilities you’ve been looking for are already there. You’ve just been keeping the people who possess them rather busy.

Murray-Turner-Flow-State

Flow State and Personal Resilience: How to Keep Growing

Flow state and personal resilience: explore how to keep growing by finding new challenges as your skills and interests

Murray-Turner-era-of-standard-deviation

The Era of Standard Deviation: Why Business Must Rethink Success

I’ve started writing this blog about half a dozen times. Not because I don’t know what I want to[…]

Solveig Løvseth at Kona celebrating with another athlete near the IRONMAN finish line

The Resilience to Redefine Victory: Solveig Løvseth at IRONMAN Kona

Solveig Løvseth’s remarkable IRONMAN Kona finish reveals how resilience can mean changing course, recognising our limits and redefining victory.

One response

Leave a Reply

Your email address will not be published. Required fields are marked *